Full disclosure – I’ve long been a fan of many of Google’s services. I’ve used Gmail since the first beta, rely on Google search all day long, use a Pixel as my smartphone and listen to music all day long through their music service. It pains me when my favorite tech brands make poor choices, and unfortunately, Googles leadership seem to have forgotten their founders original scree, “Don’t be evil,” in favor of behaving like any profit-driven, ethically-ambiguous megacorp. The latest scandal comes from one of Google’s recent tech acquisitions in the form of a failure to disclose the presence of microphones in the Nest Secure home devices. Now, the presence of microphones in security devices shouldn’t come as a surprise, but Google’s failure to mention it in any documentation is a glaring breach of trust on their part.
What this means for you
When I first heard this news, I though to myself, “Well duh, of course these things have microphones. They are security monitoring devices,” and thought that, once again, naive consumers were purchasing and installing the devices without RTFM (“reading the fine manual” except substitute your own f-word). But no, Google (and Nest) didn’t actually document the presence of a microphone at all until it recently revealed that the Google Assistant technology could now be used on the Nest Secure device which, oh by the way, uses voice control…which, erm, requires a microphone…that is already on the device. According to Google, the microphone was disabled by default and can only be activated when the user specifically enables it. Which doesn’t make the whole failure to disclose any better, because how do we know it wasn’t enabled, and why should we trust them to be telling the truth now?
Unfortunately for you, even if you were being a careful consumer and reading the fine manual (or label, or reviews, etc.) the only way you would have known there was a microphone in the device would have been to dismantle it yourself, but why would you do that because the product documentation clearly lists the device’s specs, doesn’t it? Does this sound familiar? Like some other technology megacorp abusing its users’ trust? Is it going to take dragging these companies in front of Congress to get them stop being so lackadaisical with our privacy? Well, before we do that, let’s make sure we elect Congress critters that know iPhones aren’t made by Google.
